Good American Family is a drama series that premiered on Hulu on March 19, 2025. The show is based on a real-life story and follows the experiences of a family who adopts a child under unusual circumstances. The story focuses on Natalia, a young girl from Ukraine with dwarfism, who is adopted by Kristine and Michael Barnett. At first, the couple is excited to welcome her into their home, but over time, they begin to question whether she is actually a child—or an adult pretending to be one.

The series presents different perspectives, allowing viewers to see the events through both the parents’ and Natalia’s eyes. The Barnetts claim that Natalia exhibits behaviors that make them suspicious, leading them to take drastic actions, such as changing her legal age and eventually leaving her to live on her own. However, as the series progresses, it also explores Natalia’s side of the story, making it difficult to determine who is telling the full truth. This approach keeps the audience engaged and encourages critical thinking about the situation.

One of the strongest aspects of the show is its performances. Imogen Faith Reid delivers a convincing portrayal of Natalia, balancing innocence and mystery in a way that keeps viewers guessing. Ellen Pompeo and Mark Duplass, who play the adoptive parents, bring emotional depth to their roles, showing how uncertainty and fear affect their decisions. The supporting cast, including Christina Hendricks and Dulé Hill, also adds to the emotional weight of the series.

The pacing of the show builds suspense gradually. While some moments may feel slow, they serve to develop the characters and highlight the psychological tension within the family. Instead of exaggerating the drama, the show focuses on how misunderstandings, fear, and assumptions shape the way people view each other. This makes the story feel more realistic and thought-provoking.

Overall, Good American Family is a well-acted and engaging series that presents a controversial real-life case in a compelling way. By showing multiple sides of the story, it challenges viewers to question their own perceptions and consider how complicated the truth can be. Whether or not audiences agree with how the story is told, the series leaves a lasting impression.